She slid into the back of the pre-booked town car, the leather cool against her skin. The New York skyline blurred past the window, a familiar landscape that felt different today, charged with the secret she was carrying. Her thumb instinctively found the cool metal of her wedding ring, tracing its smooth, unbroken circle. Three years. It felt like a lifetime and no time at all.
She pulled out her phone, her fingers flying across the screen.
"Guess what anniversary present I got for you?"
She hit send, then switched the phone to silent, tucking it away in her purse. The surprise had to be perfect.
The car turned onto a familiar street in the Upper East Side, pulling to a smooth stop before a limestone tower that scraped the sky. Kaitlynn took a deep breath, the city air thick with possibility. She pictured Julian's face, the way his serious expression would break into surprise, then hopefully, into that rare, genuine smile she loved.
She keyed in the code to their private elevator, the soft chime announcing her ascent. The doors opened directly into their apartment foyer. It was quiet. Too quiet.
She slipped off her shoes, her movements soft, wanting to sneak up behind him at his desk, wrap her arms around his shoulders, and feel his familiar scent.
But her gaze snagged on something by the shoe cabinet. A pair of Manolo Blahniks, a sharp, strappy stiletto style she didn't own, were placed carelessly beside Julian's loafers.
A strange, cloying sweet scent hit her next. Gardenias. It was heavy, suffocating, a stark contrast to the subtle, woody fragrance she preferred. Her heart gave a hard, painful thump against her ribs.
Her steps faltered as she moved towards the living room. Draped over the arm of their cream-colored sofa was a beige trench coat. It was a woman's, tailored and modern. It wasn't her mother-in-law's. Diana Sinclair wouldn't be caught dead in something so... young.
Then she heard it. A soft, feminine laugh drifting from the open-plan study.
"Julian, you're always so good to me."
The blood in Kaitlynn's veins turned to ice. Her knuckles were white where she gripped the handle of her suitcase. The metal felt cold enough to burn.
She moved without making a sound, her body on autopilot, until she reached the edge of the study's doorway. Through the gap, she saw a scene that stole the air from her lungs.
Julian was at his desk, his back to her. Standing beside him, leaning in close, was his secretary, Ava Miller.
His hand was in Ava's hair, his fingers gently tucking a stray strand behind her ear. The gesture was intimate, effortless, practiced.
Ava's face was tilted up towards him, a picture of blissful contentment. A flicker of something-triumph, maybe-flashed in her downcast eyes before it was gone.
Kaitlynn felt like an intruder in her own home. A wave of nausea and sharp, gut-wrenching humiliation washed over her.
She made a sound. A small, choked gasp for air.
Their heads snapped in her direction.
Julian's eyes widened in shock, a flicker of panic in their depths. He snatched his hand back from Ava's hair as if he'd been burned. He shot to his feet.
"Kaitlynn? What are you doing back early?"
Ava, for her part, mastered a look of wide-eyed surprise, a blush of innocent fear coloring her cheeks. She took a half-step back, creating a respectable distance.
"Mrs. Sinclair, I... we were just discussing work."
Kaitlynn's gaze was glacial. It swept over Ava once, dismissively, before landing on her husband. Her voice was brittle, each word a shard of glass.
"Julian, do you know what day it is?"
His expression went blank. A flicker of confusion, then a dawning horror as he clearly searched his memory and found nothing. He opened his mouth, but no sound came out.
Ava stepped in, her voice a sweet, helpful murmur. "It's your wedding anniversary, isn't it? Julian was just mentioning he wanted to do something special to celebrate."
The "reminder" was a dagger, twisting in the wound. It confirmed he had forgotten, and worse, his secretary had remembered.
Julian's face flushed with embarrassment. He moved towards her, reaching for her suitcase. "I'm sorry, honey. Work has been insane lately. I..."
Kaitlynn pulled the suitcase back, out of his reach. Her voice was ice. "So this is how you celebrate? Working late at home with your secretary?"
Ava's eyes immediately filled with tears. Her lower lip trembled. "Mrs. Sinclair, you've misunderstood. I was just helping Julian with the quarterly report. He's been working so hard."
Julian's protective instincts flared instantly. "Kaitlynn, don't. Ava was just helping me. I asked her to stay."
He glanced at his watch, a desperate attempt to salvage the situation. "Now that you're back, let's go out to dinner. A proper celebration. Ava's worked hard too, she should come with us."
The suggestion hung in the air, so absurd, so utterly tone-deaf that Kaitlynn felt the world tilt on its axis. An anniversary dinner for three.
She looked at Julian's earnest, oblivious face. She looked at Ava's poorly concealed look of eager anticipation behind her feigned surprise. A bitter, metallic taste filled her mouth.
She didn't scream. She didn't cry.
She smiled. A thin, sharp, terrifying smile.
"Okay," she said, her voice unnervingly calm. "Let's all go together."